Wow – Verdicts Overturned in 30-Year Old DUI Cases
If a judge had accepted your guilty plea case involving a Los Angeles DUI, and new evidence turned up, would you take the time and spend the money to have that verdict overturned? What if your conviction dated all the way back to 1986? Some people in Massachusetts who pleaded guilty to DUI are willing to do it.
A recent article in the Vineyard Gazette (the newspaper for the upscale Martha’s Vineyard) reported that attorneys who practice in the Edgartown District Court are taking a look at the operating under the influence (OUI) cases handled by Judge Brian Rowe over his 20 years in office. When accepting an accused DUI driver’s guilty plea, Judge Rowe apparently neglected to follow a procedure called colloquy. According to the Gazette, the judge was supposed to advise the guilty party that he/she had the right to a jury trial if desired and to ask each defendant if he or she fully understood the consequences of the decision to make a guilty plea. There’s a box on some court forms that the judge should have checked if the discussion had taken place.
The move to reopen Rowe’s OUI cases came about because some lawyers were looking at ways to reduce the potential penalties for clients facing second DUI charges. Several former attorneys, including a defense lawyer, a former prosecutor turned defense lawyer and a criminal defense attorney, swore in court affidavits that they had never seen Rowe follow the proper steps for a colloquy. Due to the testimony, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts has dismissed the original charges in at least two OUI cases, and it is examining at least seven more. (Judge Rowe, who retired 11 years ago, hasn’t commented on the rulings.)
In most states, any conviction for DUIs after the first brings increasingly severe penalties. Under California Vehicle Code 23152, for example, the minimum jail time for a first offense (96 hours) increases to 10 days.
Los Angeles DUI defense lawyer, Michael Kraut, of the Kraut Law Group is standing by to offer critical insight into your case and potential defense options. Call him and his team today to begin regaining control over your case and your life.